top of page
Search

Why AI Resume Reviews Miss Your Biggest Strengths

Nov 11
3 min read

I've reviewed plenty of resumes from people who have impressive experience but aren't getting interviews. Sometimes they've already spent hours using ChatGPT or Claude to improve their resume, comparing it against job descriptions, rewriting bullet points, and making sure they've included the right keywords.


And it looks....ok.


But when I start asking questions about their experience, I discover things that would make them considerably more interesting to a recruiter. Things that weren't on the resume at all.


That's just one of the problems with relying on AI to tell you whether your resume is doing its job.


Matching the Job Description Only Gets You So Far


Let's say you're a senior operations professional applying for Director-level positions. You upload your resume and a job posting to ChatGPT and ask it to make your experience more relevant to the opportunity.


It identifies the employer's priorities and rewrites your bullet points to emphasize operational efficiency, cross-functional leadership, process improvement, and strategic planning. All relevant qualifications. But plenty of other applicants have those same skills and responsibilities.


What I'd want to know as a recruiter is what you've actually accomplished that makes your experience worth paying attention to. Maybe you took over a department that had been missing its performance targets for years and turned it around. Maybe you inherited a team with serious retention problems and improved turnover without increasing compensation. Or maybe you managed a much larger operation than someone with the same job title at another company.


Those details could make a significant difference in how a recruiter evaluates you. But if they weren't included in the information you gave AI, there's a good chance they won't appear in the revised resume either.


The Questions That Change a Resume


When I'm working with a resume client, I don't just ask what their responsibilities were or what accomplishments they want to include. I want to understand the circumstances behind their experience.


If someone tells me they improved a process, I'll want to know what wasn't working before, what they changed, and whether the results were considered successful. If they managed a team, I'll want to understand its size, the challenges they inherited, and what improved under their leadership.


Sometimes the most valuable information comes out of those conversations. I've worked with people who barely mentioned accomplishments that I thought deserved considerable attention. They didn't think those details were particularly impressive because they'd been doing that kind of work for years. But from a recruiting perspective, those were exactly the things that could help distinguish them from other candidates.


And sometimes I discover that the person is emphasizing experience that isn't particularly relevant to the positions they're pursuing, while giving very little attention to accomplishments that would make a much stronger case for hiring them.

You can rewrite a resume as many times as you want, but if you're emphasizing the wrong things, better wording isn't going to fix that.


What You're Actually Paying for in a Resume Review


After more than 20 years in recruiting, I've spent a lot of time evaluating candidates and working with hiring managers to understand what they're looking for.


That experience is what I bring to my resume reviews and rewrites.


I'm looking at your background from the perspective of someone deciding whether you're worth interviewing. I'm trying to identify what makes your experience relevant, what distinguishes you from people with similar qualifications, and what might be missing or creating the wrong impression.


Sometimes the result is a relatively straightforward change to how something is presented. Other times, we uncover accomplishments or responsibilities that fundamentally change how the resume communicates your qualifications.


AI doesn't automatically know which parts of your career a recruiter would find most compelling. And matching the language of a job posting doesn't necessarily make you more competitive against everyone else applying.


If you've been using AI to improve your resume but still aren't getting interviews, it may be worth having someone evaluate what's actually being communicated.


A professional resume review can help identify what recruiters might be missing. And if your resume needs more substantial work, my resume rewrite services focus on figuring out what makes your experience valuable and making sure that comes through.


Your resume has to do more than just show that you meet the job requirements. It needs to give recruiters a reason to choose you.

 
 
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page